(850) 808-7882

Get Your Pool Cleaning Quote in less than 24 hrs

Pool Blog

Automatic pool cleaner and skimmer net beside a swimming pool for routine maintenance.

Robotic vs. Suction Pool Cleaners: Pros and Cons

Every weekend you are at it with a brush on the pool? And still not certain if a robotic or suction cleaner is what your backyard calls for? You may be asking which of the two will in fact put time and money back in your pocket down the road.

We get those questions frequently here at Terry’s Pool Service, the local pool care team for Tallahassee, FL and vicinity. In our 30 plus years of hands-on work we have put just about every make of cleaner to the test. Give us a ring at (850) 808-7882 for an honest assessment of what suits your pool.

An automatic cleaner is a matter of how your pool is made, your budget and how much upkeep you want to handle on your own. We will go over the two most popular choices below.

What Is a Suction Pool Cleaner?

It is a device that ties into the filtration system already in your pool. The pump provides the suction to move it along the walls and floor where it gathers debris and puts it right in the filter.

They have been with us a long time and are still the go to for many in this part of town. They are unpretentious, easy to put in place and do not cost much.

The case for a suction cleaner:

  • Less to put out of pocket than a robot
  • Fewer parts to break
  • It is powered by your pump so no other source is required
  • Basic cleaning of the floor and walls is reliable
  • A simple install and removal

Then again they are not without fault. Since they take from your filtration system they add to the workload of the pump and filter. This can translate to more energy use and having to clean the filter with greater frequency.

Some things to be aware of:

  • Higher energy costs as they run off your pump
  • Your skimmer loses some suction when one is in operation
  • Fine debris is often left behind and the filter has to be emptied
  • Their random movements mean they can miss areas
  • Not as adept at climbing walls as others

What Is a Robotic Pool Cleaner?

These are self-sufficient with their own motor and filter basket. One simply plugs it in and it goes about its business separate from your pump and filtration.

There is a reason for the popularity of these units. They are efficient and get the job done well without putting any undue stress on your equipment.

Advantages include:

  • Will cover the floor, walls and waterline
  • No strain on the pump or filter
  • Energy efficient in the long run
  • Has its own basket for the finer bits of dirt
  • Organized patterns for better coverage

You do pay for that kind of performance. They are pricier to buy and being electronic, a repair is not as straightforward should something fail.

The cons:

  • More expensive than the average suction model
  • Electronics can be complex to fix
  • Afterward you have to lift it out and empty the basket
  • Some are unwieldy and heavy

Which One Is Right for Your Pool?

It depends. A suction unit is fine if you want to keep it simple and inexpensive. For better coverage and lower operating costs a robotic is usually worth the outlay.

Other factors are the size of the pool, the surface and what kind of debris you have. If you have a lot of trees overhanging or an older pump it makes a difference.

You need not decide on your own. Our in-house department works on pool cleaners daily and as an authorized Hayward dealer and warranty center we can see you through the purchase and installation.

We see too many homeowners put in the wrong thing and be none the wiser for it. A word with a pro can prevent that frustration and save you some cash.

Talk to Your Neighborhood Pool Care Team

Terry’s Pool Service is on hand if you want us to pick out a cleaner, make a repair or take the whole maintenance burden off your shoulders. We are fully licensed and insured in Florida under CPC1459507 and stand behind our Done Right Guarantee.

Our office is open 8:00am to 5:00pm Monday to Friday. Call (850) 808-7882 and we will put your pool in good order.

Call today for

a quote!